The McElroys take sibling rivalry to a new level
The McElroy brothers explore video game history in a new episode of Shelf Quest, showcasing rare and beloved titles from NES classics to modern favorites at a New York store.
Griffin and Justin McElroy visited Videogames New York to curate a selection of video game cartridges for their podcast Shelf Quest, highlighting titles spanning decades of gaming history. The brothers examined NES classics like Shadowgate alongside modern favorites such as Persona 4 Golden, demonstrating their expertise in identifying standout games across eras.
During the episode, the McElroys discussed the controversial reception of David Cage’s Heavy Rain, offering their perspectives on the game’s narrative and reception among fans. They also revisited the Kinect peripheral, reflecting on its unique features and impact on console gaming despite its niche market presence.
A notable moment in the episode centered on Griffin McElroy’s gold Ocarina of Time cartridge, which he revealed had been lost over time. The discussion highlighted the sentimental and monetary value collectors place on rare gaming memorabilia.
Shelf Quest continues to blend humor, nostalgia, and deep dives into gaming culture, with the McElroys’ signature conversational style guiding viewers through their selections and personal anecdotes about the titles they feature.