No, I am not evil for wanting to turn space whale city-builder Beyond These Stars into a Moby Dick simulator
A writer argues that *Beyond These Stars*’ city-builder ethos lacks meaningful ecological consequence without embracing deliberate neglect, despite its space whale setting and sustainability mechanics.
The author describes their role as a benevolent Space Whale Mayor in *Beyond These Stars*, balancing city growth with care for Kewa, the living whale beneath their settlements. They highlight efforts to restore polluted rivers, expand forests, and maintain citizen morale through infrastructure like playgrounds and fountains. The narrative emphasizes a philosophy of mutual thriving, contrasting it with exploitative city-builders like *Factorio*.
Despite enjoying the game’s three hours of play, the author questions whether *Beyond These Stars* can escape the 'cosy' trap of eco-friendly builders. They argue that sustainable games often lack the harsh consequences of real environmental neglect, making ecological themes feel ornamental rather than impactful. The piece frames the game’s narrative—Kewa’s amnesia and potential dark memories—as a missed opportunity for deeper ecological storytelling.
The author critiques the game’s interface, citing convoluted systems for tracking production chains, such as power plants failing due to misplaced lumberjacks. They note the hexagonal grid’s visual disconnect from building layouts, which complicates spatial planning. Despite these frustrations, they praise the organic research system, where tech unlocks tie to in-game achievements rather than abstract points.
The writer expresses a desire to subvert the game’s sustainability themes by deliberately harming Kewa in sandbox mode, aiming to create a 'crazed and depressed Space Whale.' They highlight the game’s scenarios, including planet-only builds and punishing sandbox settings, as tools to explore ecological neglect. The piece concludes by directing readers to *Beyond These Stars*’ Steam page, noting its October 16 launch.